We tested 9 popular pumpkin cookie recipes in search of the chewiest, the cakiest, the fudgiest!

These Crumbl Hazelnut sea salt cookies are made with a soft and chewy sugar cookie base and topped with Nutella and flaky sea salt.

If you love Payday candy bars, here’s a Payday cookie bars version just for you.

Samoas cookies are full of delicious flavors including a buttery shortbread base, rich dark chocolate, and caramel coconut mixture topping.

Spooky, cute, and oh so delicious Mummy Brownies! Every bite is rich, chocolate-y, and just melts in your mouth. They’re the best treat!

Some of your favorite Halloween treats, chopped up and tossed into these Leftover Halloween Candy Cookies for a decadent dessert.

These bakery-style Brown Butter Chocolate Chip Cookies are full of flavor and have the most addictive chewy center!

These chocolate Halloween Sugar Cookies are a simple way to add a little Halloween magic to school lunches or Halloween parties.

These soft and chewy brown butter snickerdoodles use simple pantry ingredients and have no dough chilling time.

These Crumbl berries and cream cookies are fruity cookies topped with a simple dollop of whipped cream and generous swirls of jam.

These cookies are everything you have ever needed. They are tangy, and buttery too. You can make them with homemade custard or store bought!

Chocolate Sugar Cookies made with Dutch-processed cocoa create a rich chocolate taste along with the undertone of molasses.

These Salted Caramel Cookies are always popular! The flavor combination is too good to miss.

These frosted pumpkin sugar cookies are a perfect fall treat! Recipes + a video showing how to pipe the frosting.

Black Cocoa Halloween Cookies with Butterscotch & Espresso. Chewy, fudgy, fun, easy to make and not just for the kids!

Easy, one bowl, hot chocolate cookies made with hot cocoa mix, topped with a marshmallow fluff & candy canes. A great Christmas cookie.

Pie Crust Cookies are made with flaky pie crust, cinnamon, and sugar. They take little effort to whip up and resemble a cinnamon roll!

These are so fun for any cookie tray! Chocolate cookies are made into a cup, filled w/ a creamy mint frosting, & topped with an Andes Mint!

Chinese walnut cookies are called Hup Toh Soh (核桃酥) in Chinese. It is made with crushed walnut, flour, sugar, and egg.

Sweet snickerdoodle bread has a soft and moist cake with swirls of cinnamon sugar, then topped with the most delicious cinnamon sugar crust.

Experience a buttery crisp pastry & perfect crunch as you bite into this Chocolate and Walnut Rugelach with a soft cinnamon-spiced spread.

An easy-to-make, stunning dessert! Sweet, tart, creamy and so pretty, this no-bake cheesecake will always draw a crowd.